Harry Potter theory stolen from someone who stole it from someone else
WARNING: SPOILER FOR HARRY POTTER AND THE HALFBLOOD PRINCE- DON'T READ BEFORE BOOK 6!!!
from http://www.markshea.blogspot.com/
John Granger, Author of Looking for God in Harry Potter Weighs in......on the Harry Potter discussion that has been going on here. He writes:
Sean is right in his presentation of my opinion that Dumbledore does not ask for his death or for mercy on the Tower ("Severus, please..."). He only asks that their connection be broken and his death become final. Read that "Sever Us, please." When Snape asks his DADA class what the difference is between a ghost and an Inferi, the correct answer is "Albus Dumbledore," whose de-animation has been suspended for a period (not more than a year) by the Stoppered Death potion mentioned in the first Potions class in the series (a class referred to 7 times in HP6). As Joyce Odell has written, cogently I think, Dumbledore is Snape's "handler" and has done everything to protect him - to include lying out right about how much Snape heard of the Prophecy. He trusts him as much as he does for a variety of reasons, but most obviously in his last year because he knows he is only among the living because of Snape's "connection."
J. showed it to me...what do you think? (and anyone have more info on this death stopper reference besides it's mention in Snape's intro to the class?)
from http://www.markshea.blogspot.com/
John Granger, Author of Looking for God in Harry Potter Weighs in......on the Harry Potter discussion that has been going on here. He writes:
Sean is right in his presentation of my opinion that Dumbledore does not ask for his death or for mercy on the Tower ("Severus, please..."). He only asks that their connection be broken and his death become final. Read that "Sever Us, please." When Snape asks his DADA class what the difference is between a ghost and an Inferi, the correct answer is "Albus Dumbledore," whose de-animation has been suspended for a period (not more than a year) by the Stoppered Death potion mentioned in the first Potions class in the series (a class referred to 7 times in HP6). As Joyce Odell has written, cogently I think, Dumbledore is Snape's "handler" and has done everything to protect him - to include lying out right about how much Snape heard of the Prophecy. He trusts him as much as he does for a variety of reasons, but most obviously in his last year because he knows he is only among the living because of Snape's "connection."
J. showed it to me...what do you think? (and anyone have more info on this death stopper reference besides it's mention in Snape's intro to the class?)
posted by Etrangère | 1:08 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home